The church was designed by E. W. Pugin and was built to accommodate 1,000 people. Fr. Brierley, the parish priest at the time, and responsible for the building of the church, had a particular devotion to Our Lady, and the church was dedicated to 'Our Lady of the Sacred Heart'.
The original church, which was opened in 1853, was then taken over for use as part of St. Mary's school, which adjoined it.